Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Poverty numbers

Bill Easterly: There is an obscure piece of theoretical statistics called “garbage in, garbage out.” Calculating “additional poor in poverty due to crisis” requires (a) knowing what growth would have been in absence of crisis in every country, (b) knowing what growth will actually turn out to be in 2009 or 2010 in every country, not to mention in 2008, since the World Bank’s World Development Indicators do not yet have estimates for that year, (c) having good data on the current level of world poverty, (d) knowing the effect of growth on poverty, (e) projecting the effect of food and fuel prices on poverty, not to mention projecting food and fuel prices.

The reality: (a) is impossible, (b) is almost impossible, (c) Voices of the Vulnerable says the last real global poverty numbers were in 2005, which themselves reflected an upward revision of 40 percent ,(d) is unreliable and volatile, and (e) is impossible.

the rest is here

-------------------------------------------------
DiggIt!Add to del.icio.usShare on Facebook

1 comment:

ALEssandro LOrenzo CAmilla said...

ugo, giusto perche' vuole essere un bastian contrario... has he read ravallion, chen? (53 is the effect in 2009, 91 is the effect by 2010). and piece on vox makes some assumptions about what the growth assumptions are. mah...